In the past few months, we’ve had a number of family and friends share their concern that our travel will cause long-term emotional and psychological damage to our children. The concerns shared with us include the difficulty of making friends (especially long term friends), and a sense of ‘not belonging’ caused by not having a single place to call home.
It’s happened enough times now that I thought we should share our thoughts on the issue. Before I get started, I want to make clear that we are not offended by these concerns. They come from family and friends who love us, and they or those they know have struggled with these issues as a result of frequently moving during their childhood years. We are honored that they care enough for us to be concerned for the welfare of our kids. The thoughts we share here relate to our family, and are not intended to cast judgement upon the struggles of others.
Why ARE we traveling with our kids?
Over two years prior to starting our full-time travel, we’ve observed the effects that our travel has had on our family. In two separate, weeks long trips, we began to notice changes in both our children and ourselves as parents. The kids are filled with a sense of wonder and learning. They became much better friends with each other, becoming allies instead of enemies. Jess and I found ourselves much more aware of each child’s accomplishments and struggles. We found ourselves in a much better position to connect with them, to guide them and teach them as they grow.
THAT is our reason for travel. Neither Jess or I had goals that included the types of travel we are engaged in. Though excited by the possibilities that this lifestyle affords, we still have not set goals for a certain time or distance traveled. We will travel until it is no longer right for our family. We have plans, goals, and desires that are unable to be fulfilled during travel. As soon as the right thing for our family requires something different, we will make the required changes and fill those needs.
We travel FOR our kids, not in spite of them.
We believe that a family is the strongest bond and association that kids can have, and that no other organization can fulfill the needs as well as a family can. We believe that a strong sense of family identity is one of the most important things that will help children form their own identity. Knowing who they are stems from who their family is, and will help them relate to others more easily.
I grew up without a TV in the house because my parents deliberately chose not to have one. The friends I made at school all connected with each other through the television shows they watched, and I was unable to do so. As parents of three (later four) young boys, my parents established a pattern of hard physical labor. Our ability and willingness to work became central to our family identity. That family identity helped me form my own identity, one rooted in my ability to work. That identity made it easier to relate to other kids, despite the differences in our families and childhood experiences.
We believe that our travel and exploration will contribute to our family’s identity. We believe that seeing new places and meeting new people will expand the vision and understanding of our children, while giving them a stronger sense of who we are as a family, and they are as individuals. We are deliberately forming our family identity around WHO we are, and not WHERE we are from. Our children will surely live in various places in their life, but a sense of WHO our family is and WHO they are can conveniently travel wherever they go.
But what about friends?
Being friendly is an attribute being actively developed in our traveling children. As they meet other children along the way, they have learned how to quickly make friends, and get right down to having fun with minimal delay. Some of these other kids are met at campgrounds and state and national parks, and many are the kids of friends and family that we visit along the way.
Our kids do have long term friends, and we help them maintain these friendships though letters, phone calls, and video chats. We even use our travel to help those friendships, as we are currently on our way to meet some friends for a vacation in California. We will continue to support our children’s friendships, old and new, as we continue our travels.
So how long will we travel?
As an interesting note, those who have shared concerns with us have become concerned when they realize that our travels do not have a pre-defined end date. It appears that not the length of travel, but the undecided end of travel is the primary concern. Though I have not asked them, I suspect they would not have similar concerns if we announced that we wanted to set out on a 12 month trip around the country.
Let’s call it that then. Consider us on a 12 month trip around the country. Just be aware that it might be longer, and it might be shorter. We’ll know when we are done.
Identify Yourselves
Having benefited ourselves from a strong sense of family identity, we encourage that in other families. Your identity need not be centered around travel, or hard physical labor. It should also not be a carbon copy of another family identity, but uniquely your own, crafted to fit the needs of each family member. What is your family identity?
I think the fact that you are doing it because you saw that it was drawing your family closer together is a good thing. The opportunity for your kids to learn to make friends quickly is a skill that will bless them all their lives. I also really like that you don’t have a predetermined date for when you will be done traveling. This allows you to continue to travel until it is right for your family to change to something else that serves you all better when that time comes.
I moved a lot as a kid. I went to three different schools in the third grade. My struggles weren’t from the changing schools, but the instability at home. My parents were divorced and my mom moved around to get work. She married again and divorced and married again for the last time. All my parents, step and biological, struggled with their own major emotional issues that affected us.
That’s the difference. You and Jess are creating stability through your healthy marriage. You have routine and habits and rules. Your children feel a deep sense of belonging to you instead of something more ephemeral like friends or location. I think I would have preferred a stable family than a stable location.
Thanks for sharing this Cassie. Your sweet girl is in good hands!
We’ve had similar conversations…and have posted some entries in the area as well:
http://boyinks4adventure.com/our-travels/but-what-about-friends/
http://boyinks4adventure.com/our-travels/being-that-family/
Thanks for the links! Both your posts are well written and insightful.
You shared your thoughts into words beautifully. These are good reminders as we may move around a lot.
If you can turn a move into family-strengthening event, then everybody wins!
Thanks for writing this. We also get these questions and your response is exactly how we feel.
It is comforting to know we are in good company! Your travels have inspired us.
Tyler and I wonder if we’re damaging our children by NOT traveling. Do they live in a bubble? Do they have any sense of the world? Then we think, they’re little–there’s plenty of time for that. Your kids are young, they aren’t in a friend-dominated stage of life yet. We are so jealous of all the adventures (just the good ones) you’re having. I think this will be nothing but good for them. And like you point out, if it stops being good for them, you’ll be the first to notice.
Thanks for the note Kristen – I actually laughed out loud at this one. Though we love Lehi, Jess and I are in part motivated by the bubble effect that exists.
It’s all about what your kids need and when, and I’m sure you’ll find the right thing at the right time for them.
We never had anyone express concerns to us, only supportive comments like, “What a great gift to give your kids! They will never forget this.” However, we were only at it for a year. Now that we are finished I can honestly say it truly did give us a stronger sense of family identity and drew us even closer together. I can echo what you said about how quickly kids make friends in a campground and how much more attentive we became as parents. There is just something about being all crammed into 360 square feet for twelve months…
Thanks Jenni!! Yes, most people don’t bat an eye when you tell them you are taking a year off to travel the country. Its the undetermined end date that gets us. We’ve seriously considering just not bringing it up at times. 🙂 How’s re-entry going for you guys?
Thank you so much for sharing this! We too have had concerns from friends and family members, and you put it so well that I’m going to refer them to your post for answers 🙂
Every time we travel with kids we get so much closer to each other, more peaceful, happier, and so in-tune with each other. Once we are home – gosh – so many distractions! I absolutely agree with you that traveling creates a very strong family bong and everything else that was mentioned in this post.
Eve – thanks so much for your comment!